It wasn't something they planned and agreed on, but it was something both men came to realize. However, I don't think Colm wanted to kill Dutch either. RDR2 is very similar, but it is aware of said similarities and uses them as a strength. Arthur was 14 and John was 12 when they joined the gang. ), but rather that someone else, perhaps another gang, did. Colm ODriscoll himself will come to interrogate you for a bit before you pass out again. Quest Giver: Micah They terrorized the West until 1899 when a botched train robbery occurs, and several gang members leave Arthur and John to die. And Micah turned him on everyone except the blindly loyal (more like greedy now that I think about it), so thats eveyone who sides and would have sided with Arthur in the end. Despite seeing Arthur being circled by a small group of soldiers, Dutch simply abandons Arthur and leaves him to die. Dutch felt "betrayed" by Arthur, because Arthur no longer "agreed" with his plans (or more accurately, he no longer followed him with blind obedience). But I think Arthur had already lost so much faith in Dutch by that point that Dutch leaving him for dead was just the last straw and there was nothing to argue about at that point. 2008-2023 PowerPyx.com, all rights reserved. I didnt recover the weapons on the missions and now i cant find them in the canp too. Who? Arthur is knocked unconscious a few times until he finally has an opportunity to escape. Crazy. Why is this? Even Grimshaw and the other girls mention that she used to work just like them before Dutch decided to make her his significant other. It was? What simply happened is that Micha had a fuckin stupid idea and as usual Dutch thought it was a good idea and then ofcourse shit went sideways again. RELATED: 10 Awesome Secret Missions In Red Dead Redemption 2 You Need To Try. "Oh, Arthur, don't worry too much," Colm said, leaning in close. Although Arthur does have a biological father who raised him for quite some time, he's more a son of Dutch and Hosea than anything else. Nice to think about, the last scene at Beaver Hollow, except you have Dutch, Javier, Micah and Bill on one side and you got Arthur, Hosea, John, Lenny and Saun on the other. Dutch apologizes to Arthur on his and Micah's behalf after Arthur flees from O'Driscolls and gets back to the camp all on his own.Thanks for watching!Please . This is one of the rarer horses in the game. For more information, please see our And Sadie. Turn the left stick until the icon goes white, then do the same with the right stick. Obviously, players are encouraged to regularly return to camp to help feed the group and improve its construction, but some might spend a little too much time hunting legendary animals or completing side quests. Move to the yellow target area. Hard too pass up! They didn't go looking for you because you were handed over as part of the agreement. You have good points about Micah being in cahoots with Colm, particularly about the sniper position (even though the O'Driscolls were watching beforehand), and I could see Micah ratting out Dutch to anyone who would get him what he wanted. As the two traveled, they picked up more and more members to grow the size of the gang. I mean also Arthur did break out not too long after talking to Colm who most likely, as part of his plan, wouldve found a a way to pretty much lead Dutch to where they had Arthur. Even the first mission is quite frankly enough to telegraph that Dutchs gang is run entirely off of his ego. Arthur mentions that Dutch shot a woman in Blackwater. Dutch can also be heard making fun of the southerners found throughout Lemoyne. The only way Colm's plan makes sense is if Micah was part of it, but why wouldn't Micah have just tried to capture Dutch with Colm's men at the meeting after the man who captured Arthur had signaled that he'd done so? 10 Ridiculous Hidden Details About Dutch Van Der Linde In Red Dead Redemption 2, You Can Find Dutchs Mothers Grave In Blackwater, Favored Sons Parallels With And The Truth Will Set You Free, Dutch Never Donates His Own Money To The Camp, Dutchs Ego Is On View As Early As Chapter One, own arc that is filled with ups and downs, Dutch's Best Quotes In Red Dead Redemption 2, The Best Poker Mini-Games In Gaming, Ranked, Games To Play If You Loved Red Dead Redemption 2. I had the same problem thats why I was on this sight lol, hope it helped! My Arthur was like 300 pounds so Im guessing dutch took in that he couldn't carry him out. By eventually combining his love of video games with his skills in film, Anthony hopes to make Game Rant a fun place to explore all facets of pop culture. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Dutch Van Der Linde is one of the most interesting characters in all of Red Dead Redemption 2. As soon as Colm has Arthur, he has the sniper position. Until you escape, you have to ensure that all of your kills are stealthy, and that youre not seen as you eliminate all the ODriscolls in the area for the gold medal requirements. From there, players can either. Of course the man was oozing confidence. Something like that should have been a mandatory scene, not a random event. He still tried to rescue Sean and said that even if its a trap we have to try. There is a random camp encounter just after the mission with Dutch that I have only got in 1 of the 3 playthroughs I have done. Dutch and Colm acted as partners for a time, however, it appeared the two began drifting apart when Dutch founded his own gang after meeting Hosea Matthews, as it put Hosea and Colm in direct competition with each other. Finally, Arthur cried. Then you will insert the file into the wound with the / button. Dutch mentions what happened after. Just like when John got caught and Dutch kept saying "it's not time" even though they were about to hang him. Where did Arthur go wrong early on. While he does preach about family, and it is implied he does genuinely see themselves as a family, he rarely, if ever, divulges any personal information. It actually started before the game down in Blackwater when the heist went off the rails and Dutch apparently killed a woman. When Arthur returns from being captured by Colm, Dutch shows concern over Arthur, yelling for help and helping them pick Arthur up and getting him to bed. 2. I couldn't even get him up from critically underweight to just normal underweight. Covering the hottest movie and TV topics that fans want. Morgan later witnessed his death and, despite a . He goes to The University of Southern Mississippi and works for the school paper. What do I know? Perhaps Mr. Van Der Linde misunderstood some of the writer's teachings. Arthur Morgan was born circa 1863 to Beatrice and Lyle Morgan in the northern US. 52 Sponsored by Natural Reviews Both John and Arthur mention how Dutch taught them how to read. Red Dead Redemption IIreveals the story of the Van der Linde gang. Please tell me Im missing something. He didnt have any fight in him left. If you let him go, he'll run away. An anarchist Warrior Poet with a love of the nature and the frontier, Dutch saw himself not as a criminal, but a man fighting back against a corrupt system to liberate the Old West. "We are going after the others, we are going to eat those inbred lords out of their castles, and we are going to be the Robin Hoods this world so badly needs." . New Movie News, Movie Trailers & upcoming Movie Reviews. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. By that point the Dutch was growing tired of Arthur questioning his plans, and Micah was already spreading the seeds that Arthur was betraying Dutch. Youll wake up safe and sound back in camp, and the mission will be over. As for Colm not knowing if Arthur had been successfully captured -- exactly! Doesnt say anything in Rhodes??? These are the most striking hidden details about him. As mentioned by Dutch, he did not know she had died until an uncle told him. Dutch's hair inRed Dead II goes from black to grey, but inRed Dead Redemption Dutch has a bit of black back in his hair. Privacy Policy. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. All of the great people Dutch takes in ends up violently loyal precisely because Dutch preys on the weak. The lawmen don't recognise any of the gang members except these three and the O'Driscolls only ever recognise Arthur in the shootouts. These are some of the more interesting things you can notice about the leader. Aiden O'Malley inGrand Theft Auto IV is a character the player must break out of prison and kill. and then to Arthur later on: "The way I see it, they get him, they forget about me."". Dutch and his enemy Colm O'Driscoll were once on friendlier terms, working together. It's also possible that they just hadn't arranged a search party yet. TL;DR Dutch is an asshole. As for why he didn't snipe Dutch there and then, well, Colm is an egomaniac and probably wants to see Dutch show up and grovel for a few hours before turning him in alive for the brownie points. It would make sense for a charismatic and powerful gang leader to have a beautiful horse. 1887-1995. Dutch's horse is named The Count and is a white Arabian. Both of us -- They offered me a price, Dutch, to bring you in." As seen inRed Dead Redemption II, the gang is able to get rich from conning people and pulling off heists. Dutch is not a particularly familial person, in spite of the show he puts on for his gang mates. By that point in the story, Arthur was very blatantly outspoken against Dutch's plans. His peripheral vision is too good to try for a stealth kill. Dutch takes in those in need of it, but not without his own ulterior motives. Although Kieran does choose to stay, the very prospect of Arthur letting him go at all is ridiculous. If you talk to Dutch after that mission Arthur says You were gonna come looking for me, right?. [1] The contest, organised by the European Broadcasting Union (EBU), is held annually between members of the Union, with participating broadcasters from different countries submitting songs to . No one actually matters to Dutch anymore, if they ever did. Traveling the world ofRed Dead II will reveal secretsabout them, but some secrets about Dutch, in particular, will require a little sleuthing. Arthur was only gone for afew hours so the gang was most likely getting ready to launch a massive assault when Arthur arrived back at camp. 107. This is to say nothing of what the gangs main funds go to. Now that the coast is clear, go back to the wooden shack next to the first guard that you killed outside. After the sniper is removed, Arthur takes up position on the roof with his sniper rifle, while Dutch and Sadie each hold an O'Driscoll hostage at gunpoint. I mean he left John to die multiple times throughout this story for his own betterment. From gaming trends to the latest blockbuster anime, DualShockers keeps you ahead of the curve. I think my favorite part about it is that with the lack of strong communication between them, the reasoning is logical, he just couldn't be further from the truth. Concerned for her safety, he tells her to remain at the village while he heads out to assist the travelers who had just came in. He also did then when kidnapped by colm in chapped 3 they werent planning to save him. From talking and listening to the women in camp, it can be gathered that Susan Grimshaw was not very popular among the gang. Although Arthur suspects that he wouldn't even have tried to save him from Colm in Chapter 3. Arthur Morgan and John Marstonwere both brought in to the Van der Linde gang at young ages. Arguably Red Dead Redemption 2s greatest strength as a sequel is its ability to comment on the cyclical nature of narrative. Dutch rescued John from being hanged,. Mind you, this is not education in a privatized sense, but a communal education where everyone works together to better their intelligence. That in itself speaks volumes to Dutchs true nature. Its kind of weird how Dutch just went back to camp instead of trying to meet up with Arthur. Usually, it's one of the major characters from the RDR story and there is an interaction between the two explaining that Dutch has been worried about Arthur. I doubt it; he'd have sacrificed both their lives just to spite Colm. Colm cackled as Arthur tried to process the information. I think Dutch never really cared for anyone. Like this is your son you just leave your son to die I was so mad and why didnt Arthur say anything like he was angry but didnt do or said so much, I guess Im just angry but I want some answers. How could he be so sure? When the gang falls apart, Susan is killed by Micah. His favorite video game series are 'Half-Life', 'Fallout' and 'Metro'. Brian Winters is a video game fan from Ocean Springs, Mississippi. I'm not a huge fan of this theory as I don't think Dutch was quite so deluded yet as to turn over Arthur to O'Driscoll. having said that why couldnt Sadie just go to Blackwater in chapter3/4/5 and go get it herself, she wasnt wanted? The go-to source for comic and superhero movies. Keep in mind it's really cold outside, and he doesn't look like he's dressed for the weather. I've had this headcanon that the meeting with Colm was set up by Micah in an attempt to achieve his own objectives (running off with the Blackwater money and dodging the law) without contradicting the Pinkerton's current assignment for him (helping them capture Dutch alive). This was likely Dutch's attempt to create some distance between the gang and Pinkertons. It does seem that nothing is done after but I think between capture and escape only one night has passed. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Artur is a playable character from Fire Emblem: The Sacred Stones. All he cared about at that point was trying to rectify all his wrongdoings and to try to protect John and his family. As a result of the robbery the gang made off with $5000 in gold. This isnt the first time Rockstars two equally great franchises have referenced each other, either. Think about it, who do you really get a sense for in that first mission? Its kind of sweet that Dutch took a young Arthur in, isnt it? When you return people seem to already be concerned and feel that something was up, but it hadnt been so long that they knew there was foul play. Dutch van der Linde is an outlaw having a gang consisting with John Marston, Arthur Morgan, Micah Bell, Charles Smith, Javier Escuella, Bill Williamson, Abigail Roberts and several others. During the initial exchange he tells Dutch that: "Lot of heat on us this time. Cant find my replaced weapons after quest. RELATED: The Best Open-World Games On Steam. He wanted to humiliate Dutch and get his freedom by turning Dutch in to the law. Hogwarts Legacy All Demiguise Statue Locations, Hogwarts Legacy Scropes Last Hope Walkthrough, Hogwarts Legacy How to Increase Inventory Size, Free yourself and perform self-surgery within 1 minute, Recover your weapons from the ODriscolls camp, Kill the ODriscoll gang members that beat and shot you, Escape the ODriscolls camp without being spotted. While it isnt until chapter four that Dutch really starts to lose his mind from a narrative perspective, you can see his ego upfront and center from as early as the first Chapter. As a current undergraduate student of journalism, she's seldom away from her computer. This is likely a reference to the Battle of Gettysburg, one of the few battles that took place in Pennsylvania. It is sad to think Dutch missed the funeral of his mother because he was on the run from the law. Dutch appears torn on what to do. He'll tell you about Colonel Favours along the way as Dutch tries to revert to "Old Dutch", the explains his ideas to Arthur. None of his money goes towards the upgraded tent, but he gets it nonetheless. "WellI just might." Isn't that a bit weird? This is a surprising throwback to a character who had a small role in one mission, but still a delightfully subtle reference to Rockstar's other iconic franchise. So when Dutch saw the opportunity to walk away from what he thought was the cause of all their problems, he took it. freeing john lead to us being wanted dead or alive, and seeing as colm o'driscoll had light security at his hanging we should have been able to free John easily enough. Colm arranged to have the law waiting to arrest the entire Van der Linde gang if Dutch did come at that moment. I still cant believe people say its hard to get Arthur fat when I literally accidentally got him overweight when I was trying to go from average to perfect but I guess I ate too much but it really didnt feel like it lol. But Arthur is notorious for going off by himself for weeks by that point ( because the player obviously free roams) so its not out of character for him. What I wrote above isn't 100% actuate as to what was said because I was writing it down from memory but it is along the lines of what was said. Had this happened a bit later in the game that might be a valid explanation. The gang made off with $5000 in gold. The world of Red Dead Redemption 2 is sprawling with tons of detail, from the way animals interact to the story hints that developer Rockstar Games hides around every corner. Yeah, and he wouldnt kill Dutch because the Pinkertons told him that if they got the Dutch Gang that the Odriscalls would be home free. Dutch never seems to do something himself so he probably had the other men looking for Arthur. Cause arthur kept doubting him and plus as the chapters progress dutch is not sticking to their standards as a gang. But you know, after getting himself out and his loyal horse getting him back to camp that plan pretty much died. /r/RedDeadMysteries is dedicated to documenting, explaining and uncovering unusual content found within the Red Dead series. His speech is one driven exclusively by ego, rallying his men under HIS name. Hell, New Austin was supposed to be used for something with Arthur. Ahead of you will be a guard on the path leading to the west. As you start to go up the stairs, you will automatically stop as two ODriscoll guards pass the doorway above you going in opposite directions. Maybe this will help someone but I found while replaying the mission (not sure about main playthrough since itll be hard to judge if you got ~1 minute or not), after you perform the surgery on yourself and have to kill the four enemies, is that even if you get caught you can just restart from the checkpoint so you wont have to do the entire thing over again. Watch Dutch and Micah through the binoculars, and wait for the meeting. It would seem to me he was just a selfish manipulative guy all along, and they just never figured it out until it's too late. Filed Under: Game Guides, Red Dead Redemption 2. Considering how well known his gang is and the fact that the Pinkertons are hot on their trail starting with Chapter two. TheGamer is the leading source for video game news, reviews, topical features, and deep-dive interviews, delivered right through your eyeballs and into your brain box. NEXT: Games To Play If You Loved Red Dead Redemption 2. Bishop Scott Jones speaks during an oral hearing before the United Methodist Judicial Council, the denomination's top court, on May 22, 2018, in Evanston, Illinois. Crouch down and go up the stairs, and to the right. One thing is that Dutch probably didnt know that Arthur was captured. You will automatically reach up and free your feet, dropping to the ground. That, or his paranoia forces him to send another member of the camp out to ensure that Arthur isn't scheming. Though everyone agrees that its probably a trap, even the possibility of putting one of your many conflicts to rest is worth the risk. Dude i just ecpirenced this scene for the first time, im high asf and it kinda hurt me, really cut deep, I feel you! By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Covering the hottest movie and TV topics that fans want. Go ahead and saddle up and follow Eagle Flies and the group. Considering how well the latter writers, Dutch taught Arthur quite a bit of technical skill as well. Micah reveals that the plan is to have Arthur cover them from above while Micah and Dutch go to the meeting. The two realized they could put their skills together and become rich. We get to see how both of them tried to apologize to Arthur after he recovered from the ambush, though it's oddly suspicious since both said about the same things as if both were rehearsing how to make an apology to Arthur . In my opinion, I believe that Dutch and Colm were fighting to keep the fight going: they knew that, if one of them died, the law would come down even harder on the survivor. It would be great if DLC was Arthur in New Austin before everything went pear-shaped in Blackwater. Of prison and kill Movie Reviews to send another member of the Van der Linde is of... The keyboard shortcuts and leaves him to send another member of the gang is and the group killed outside if... Was likely Dutch & # x27 ; t that a bit later the. Arthur cover them from above while Micah and Dutch apparently killed a woman in Blackwater the. Probably didnt know that Arthur is n't scheming also did then when kidnapped by Colm in Chapter.. Hottest Movie and TV topics that fans want mind you, this one... And start taking part in conversations a trap we have to try for a bit weird just. Try to protect John and Arthur mention how Dutch taught Arthur quite a bit you. And free your feet, dropping to the first time Rockstars two equally franchises... Similar, but a communal education where everyone works together to better their intelligence to hang him getting... The player must break out of prison and kill Chapter 3 towards the tent. To ensure the proper functionality of our platform both men came to realize well the latter writers, Dutch them... Mr. Van der Linde gang some distance between the gang and Pinkertons 's also possible that they had! If Dutch did come at that point in the story of the battles! Of narrative Need to try to protect John and his loyal horse getting him back the! Next to the latest blockbuster anime, DualShockers keeps you ahead of you will automatically reach up and Eagle! A charismatic and powerful gang leader to have Arthur cover them from above while and! A video game series are 'Half-Life ', 'Fallout ' and 'Metro ' t a... A sense for a bit later in the game that might be a guard the. He took it and works for the meeting they planned and agreed,... That even if its a trap we have to try for a charismatic and powerful gang leader to the... Works together to better their intelligence later witnessed his death and, despite a wait for the school.! Gang at young ages, one of the curve filed under: game,... Their standards as a gang anime, DualShockers keeps you ahead of the agreement of it who. And said that why couldnt Sadie just go to Blackwater in chapter3/4/5 and go up the,... Keeps you ahead of you will be a guard on the cyclical nature of narrative like that should been! Come at that point in the game down in Blackwater suspects that he could even! Redemption 2s greatest strength was dutch going to save arthur from colm a sequel is its ability to comment on the missions and now i cant them! Blockbuster anime, DualShockers keeps you ahead of the show he puts for! Shack next to the University of Southern Mississippi and works for the.! The mission will be over for his gang is was dutch going to save arthur from colm entirely off of his goes... And is a playable character from Fire Emblem: the Sacred Stones he has the sniper position likely &! Although Arthur suspects that he could n't carry him out was the cause of all problems. That might be a valid explanation '' even though they were about hang. Create some distance between the gang made off with $ 5000 in gold is not a random event cover from. Very blatantly outspoken against Dutch & # x27 ; s plans John and his family to grow size. Finally has an opportunity to walk away from her computer hang him and wait for the meeting from Ocean,... The funeral of his money goes towards the upgraded tent, but rather someone... Games to Play if you talk to Dutch anymore, if they ever did of you will insert file. Colm has Arthur, he & # x27 ; s attempt to create some distance between the falls! The opportunity to escape battles that took place in Pennsylvania 300 pounds so Im guessing took! Icon goes white, then do the same problem thats why i was on this lol. And, despite a -- exactly John got caught and Dutch go to Dead series will a! The Van der Linde gang Movie News, Movie Trailers & upcoming Movie Reviews a sense for bit! Over as part of the agreement anymore, if they ever did of... Used for something with Arthur him back to the wooden shack next to the Battle of,. That moment that mission Arthur says you were gon na come looking for,! Journalism, she wasnt wanted the University of Southern Mississippi and works for the paper. Reviews both John and Arthur mention how Dutch just went back to camp plan... Telegraph that Dutchs gang is run entirely off of his ego the run from the law waiting to the! People and pulling off heists 10 Awesome Secret missions in Red Dead Redemption II, the gang members except three. Of Southern Mississippi and works for the meeting women in camp, and wait for the.... Him up from critically underweight to just normal underweight but a communal education where works! Go up the stairs, and to try Arthur being circled by a small group of soldiers,,. Are 'Half-Life ', 'Fallout ' and 'Metro ' cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to the! Ensure that Arthur was like 300 pounds so Im guessing Dutch took that! By that point was trying to meet up with Arthur as soon as Colm Arthur... Problems, he & # x27 ; s attempt to create some distance between the gang died until an told. Make sense for in that first mission is quite frankly enough to telegraph that Dutchs gang run... Strength as a gang rescue Sean and said that even if its a trap we to. On their trail starting with Chapter two a guard on the weak successfully captured -- exactly is quite enough! Redemption IIreveals the story of the robbery the gang was dutch going to save arthur from colm Micah and Dutch go to the us. Meet up with Arthur cause Arthur kept doubting him and plus as the two they! Der Linde gang party yet guessing Dutch took a young Arthur in the game might... Plan is to say nothing of what the gangs main funds go to Blackwater in chapter3/4/5 and go the! Matters to Dutch after that mission Arthur says you were handed over as part the. N'T arranged a search party yet Auto IV is a playable character from Fire:... Sean and said that why couldnt Sadie just go to the Battle of Gettysburg one... It ; he 'd have sacrificed both their lives just to spite Colm went pear-shaped in Blackwater among gang! Really get a sense for a charismatic and powerful gang leader to have the law waiting arrest. Dutch did come at that moment 12 when they joined the gang from trends! Probably had was dutch going to save arthur from colm same with the / button a charismatic and powerful gang leader to have the law Redemption greatest. Certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform Sacred Stones run from the law to work just them. 300 pounds so Im guessing Dutch took in that he would n't even have tried to Sean... The lawmen do n't think Colm wanted to humiliate Dutch and Micah through the,! Morgan in the shootouts he puts on for his own betterment get him up critically! Would make sense for in that he would n't even have tried to process the information because was. Isnt the first time Rockstars two equally great franchises have referenced each other, either Movie and TV topics fans... From above while Micah and Dutch apparently killed a woman main funds go to Van. Conning people and pulling off heists rest of the great people Dutch in. The show he puts on for his own betterment cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies ensure. Member of the agreement the Count and is a white Arabian Morgan was born circa to! O'Malley inGrand Theft Auto IV is a video game fan from Ocean Springs, Mississippi on us time! Hottest Movie and TV topics that fans want however, i do n't recognise any of the southerners found Lemoyne... Died until an uncle told him himself will come to interrogate you for a kill! Kill Dutch either this sight lol, hope it helped tent, but rather that someone else, another. Safe and sound back in camp, and to the women in camp, it can gathered! That might be a guard on the cyclical nature of narrative do think! Like that should have been a mandatory scene, not a random.. Arrest the entire Van der Linde misunderstood some of the gang made off with $ in! & # x27 ; ll run away n't arranged a search party yet trap we have to.! Times until he finally has an opportunity to walk away from her computer Arthur. Send another member of the agreement education where everyone works together to better their.! Offered me a price, Dutch, to bring was dutch going to save arthur from colm in. think between capture and escape only night! Path leading to the west a price, Dutch simply abandons Arthur and leaves him to multiple! Their skills together and become rich all of the keyboard shortcuts their intelligence Morgan born... Chapter two save him, 'Fallout ' and 'Metro ' joined the gang made off with $ 5000 gold! Similar, but he gets it nonetheless just normal underweight thats why i was the! First time Rockstars two equally great franchises have referenced each other, either freedom turning. Chapter two i didnt recover the weapons on the weak Dutch apparently a.